Opening and closing prices
The authors studied an organisation running auctions for corporate buyers. They measured the reduction in final price relative to the lowest initial bid. The number of participating suppliers, auction format and product category were associated with the size of that reduction. Karabağ and Tan, An Empirical Analysis of the Main Drivers Affecting the Buyer Surplus in E-Auctions.
Why the purchase category matters
For a standard material, several suppliers may price the exact same specification. For a component designed into a project, offers may differ on commissioning scope, delivery date or service conditions. The researchers found that product category mattered in their sample. Separating recurring purchases from project orders can make your pilot results easier to interpret. Paper in the Erasmus University Rotterdam repository.
Set minimum requirements before comparing prices. If a line must start in ten days, a six-week delivery offer still provides market information. To measure achievable savings for that project, include offers that meet its deadline.
Two questions about one purchase
Suppose the opening offers are PLN 105 and PLN 100, and the buyer negotiates PLN 97. Relative to the best opening price the reduction is 3%. The more expensive opening offer gives a different comparison. Record the baseline before the pilot begins.
Reporting to the project manager
At 100 units the difference between PLN 100 and PLN 97 is PLN 300 before tax. If the final offer adds PLN 80 shipping that was previously included, the comparable difference is PLN 220. Record the date of the reference offer, quantity, delivery terms and amount ordered so a colleague can reproduce the result.
To separate supplier selection from negotiation, keep all three prices. Choosing PLN 100 over PLN 105 accounts for PLN 5 per unit. Negotiating the price down to PLN 97 adds another PLN 3. VendorIQ’s price calculator answers a different question by comparing groups of contracts with different numbers of received bids. Put the model estimate beside the difference from actual quotes when reporting the pilot. Calculator methodology.