Skip to content

VendorIQ

AI assistant

How can we help?

See how VendorIQ fits your procurement workflow.

Procurement research

What difference do extra bids make to the contract price?

More than 2,000 Danish public tenders reveal why the value of another bid depends on how many quotes a buyer already has.

Where does the 2.5% figure come from?

Kasper Bek Aagaard and Jesper Gregers Linaa studied tenders from 2015 to 2022. They compared the contract price with the estimated value before bidding, allowing for the type of contract and award criterion among other factors. In their first model, each additional bid received was associated with a price 2.5% lower on average. The Impact of Competition for Public Contracts on Public Finances, KFST, 2024.

What did the buyer pay for?

A large supply contract covering several plants might attract more bidders than a local order and still cost more. Comparing invoice totals would tell us little. The researchers divided the award price by the amount the buyer expected to spend before inviting bids, then compared those ratios across tenders. The sample covered goods, services and works. An automation buyer can use it as a benchmark for a market broader than industrial components.

The authors also looked at contracts that exceeded the original estimate by more than 20%. That happened in roughly 16% of tenders with one or two bids and about 9% with five. A second quote can give the buyer a reference when the first price seems unusually high. Contracts exceeding the estimate, figure 3.

When you already have two quotes

The second model estimates a separate price for each group. Compared with one bid, prices were 4.6% lower with two, 6.7% with three, 9.7% with four and 11.7% with five. Each percentage uses the same starting point. Figure 5 in the original study.

Only include the purchases for which you expect more quotes. If PLN 40,000 of a PLN 100,000 monthly budget could move from two quotes to five, the estimate applies to PLN 40,000. That gives about PLN 2,977 per month. The rest might be parts available from just one manufacturer.

Reproducing the calculation

For PLN 100,000 of comparable spend with two quotes, the starting price index is 95.4. At five quotes it is 88.3. The difference is about PLN 7,442 of current spend. Applying this public procurement relationship to private purchasing gives you a scenario to test against actual supplier quotes. Calculate your price scenario.

Explore your workflow

Let’s talk about your RFQs.

About 30 minutes: your current process, a VendorIQ example and the scope of a possible pilot.

Request a presentation