Skip to content

VendorIQ

AI assistant

How can we help?

See how VendorIQ fits your procurement workflow.

Procurement research

A second product quote in a study of 5,344 purchases

Oskari Ijäs analysed product purchases separately in Finnish public procurement. Table A.4 compares tenders with one, two and more bidders.

Which comparison is relevant to components?

The researcher matched similar tenders from 2017 to 2025. For product purchases, the matching model used 5,344 observations. The winning price with two bids was an estimated 7.9% lower than with one. With three bids the difference was 12.4%. Oskari Ijäs, Are We Paying Too Much? The Cost of Low Competition in Public Procurement, table A.4.

Reading table A.4

The table reports works, products and services side by side. For purchases of parts, look at the products column. One bid is the reference. The two-bid estimate compares the group of tenders with two bidders against those with one. Three bids are again compared with one. Adding 7.9% and 12.4% would count part of the same difference twice.

The coefficients refer to the logarithm of price. For two bids the matching coefficient is −0.082. Converting it gives a price of about 0.921 times the reference, hence the 7.9% difference. The alternative regression provides a second estimate. The shaded band on our chart shows the uncertainty around the matching estimate. Original coefficients and standard errors.

Why is the estimate higher for five offers than for seven?

The estimated reduction was 17.8% with five bids and 12.2% with seven or more. These are different groups of tenders. The published uncertainty applies to each comparison with one bid. The difference between the two estimates does not establish what would happen to the same component if its seventh quote arrived. Full chart and confidence intervals (Polish).

Checking one BOM line

Suppose a buyer needs ten identical sensors. One supplier offers PLN 210 per unit including delivery. Another offers PLN 196 per unit plus PLN 60 for shipping the batch. If both meet the technical and delivery requirements, the comparison is PLN 2,100 against PLN 2,020. The available difference is PLN 80, or about 3.8% of the first offer. A recurring part with the same reference, quantity and deadline makes a good starting point for this check.

Explore your workflow

Let’s talk about your RFQs.

About 30 minutes: your current process, a VendorIQ example and the scope of a possible pilot.

Request a presentation